#Encryption software developer sues attorney general#
Hot Topic Overview
Overview
Michael Lewellen, a researcher at cryptocurrency think tank Coin Center, recently filed a lawsuit against U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland, seeking a judicial guarantee that the Department of Justice (DOJ) will not prosecute his upcoming cryptocurrency project for violating the Money Transmission Act. Lewellen argues that DOJ criminal prosecutions of software developers who publish non-custodial cryptocurrency software, such as the charges against Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm and Samourai Wallet co-founder Keonne Rodriguez, are unconstitutional and violate the First and Fifth Amendments. His upcoming project, Pharos, is a cryptocurrency-based Kickstarter that will use smart contracts to ensure donors automatically get their funds back if the project is underfunded and features privacy functionality to protect donors' identities. Lewellen argues that as a software creator and publisher, he does not control the cryptocurrency going through Pharos, and therefore should not be considered a money transmitter. The lawsuit comes amidst growing concerns about government persecution of crypto privacy software developers, and reflects the current lack of clear regulatory and legal frameworks for cryptocurrencies.
Ace Hot Topic Analysis
Analysis
Coin Center researcher Michael Lewellen has sued U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland in Texas, asking a judge to guarantee that the Justice Department will not prosecute his upcoming cryptocurrency project for violating the Money Transmission Act. Lewellen argues that the Justice Department's criminal charges against software developers who release non-custodial cryptocurrency software, such as the charges against Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm and Samourai Wallet co-founder Keonne Rodriguez, are unconstitutional and violate the First and Fifth Amendments. He alleges that the Justice Department's prosecution of cryptocurrency developers "betrays its statements to the public" that they will not be treated as money transmitters unless they have "complete independent control" over the value transferred. Lewellen's suit comes amid growing concerns about the government's persecution of developers of crypto privacy software, both in the U.S. and abroad. Lewellen's upcoming project, Pharos, is essentially a cryptocurrency-based Kickstarter that will use a smart contract he calls a "guaranteed contract" to ensure that donors will automatically get their funds back if the project is underfunded. The project will also feature privacy features to prevent the identities of project donors from being publicly disclosed. As the creator and publisher of the Pharos software, Lewellen will only receive a pre-determined fee from successful projects. According to his lawsuit, he will "never control cryptocurrency passing through Pharos." Lewellen's lawsuit seeks to avoid the fate of Rodrigez and Storm, who face up to 45 and 25 years in prison, respectively, on charges related to their work with crypto mixing services. With a lack of clear cryptocurrency regulation and legal frameworks, preemptive lawsuits like Lewellen's are becoming increasingly common.
Public Sentiment · Discussion Word Cloud
Public Sentiment
Discussion Word Cloud
Classic Views
The Justice Department's criminal prosecution of cryptocurrency software developers violates the First and Fifth Amendments because the developers merely publish software and do not control the movement of funds.
The Justice Department's prosecution of cryptocurrency software developers is a “betrayal of its statements to the public” that it would not treat them as money transmitters unless they had “complete and independent control” over the value transferred.
The persecution of developers of encrypted privacy software by governments is intensifying, both in the United States and abroad.
In the absence of clear cryptocurrency regulation and legal frameworks, pre-emptive litigation like that of Lewellen is becoming increasingly common.